« Ericksonian Hypnosis Playing Cards | Main | The Benefits of Future Pacing »
"The Secret" About "What the Bleep Do They Know" About Quantum Mechanics
I've mentioned before how The Law of Attraction misuses the terminology of quantum physics. Well it's one thing to make that statement; I am now going to begin examining the concept a bit more closely. Many hypnotists must contend with the huge amount of misinformation out there about our field; and the antidote to misinformation is correct information (and plenty of it!).
While there might be a possibility that our neurology makes direct use of quantum effects, this has yet to be scientifically demonstrated. Recently I saw an article positing that photosynthesis makes use of a quantum effect to generate energy efficiently for plants and there could be more things in our lives built upon quantum physics than just particle accelerators. Nevertheless, it does not follow that a system for understanding what happens in the specific context of the subatomic scale (quantum theory) will necessarily play out the same way in another, very different, context. Does quantum theory mean that your mind controls and even creates reality?
Hardly. NLP acknowledges that whatever reality is out there is filtered through our senses and then through our neurology (f1 and f2 transforms). The map is not the territory. Think about this for a minute and you may realize that this does not require that the map creates the reality!
Now, sometimes people might get "results" from employing the law of attraction. As I've said in the past, I contend that this is due to the goal-seeking nature of our neurology. The "as-if frame" is a powerful one; perhaps when you act as if the law of attraction is working in your life, then you'll be more open to the opportunities around you that you hadn't noticed before. But in no way does quantum theory come into play, essentially allowing your mind to dictate what goes on "out there" in any way other than normal interaction with your environment would allow. To make assumptions that your "quantum mind" is using the "law of attraction" to affect reality is employing an "appeal to quantum mechanics".
Wikipedia says it pretty well:
Quantum quackery (appeal to quantum mechanics) are terms of the " Science wars ", criticizing the fashion trend in postmodernism , popular philosophy and various currents of pseudoscience to refer to quantum physics without any intellectual rigor or understanding of the field to provide an erudite-sounding explanation of pretty much anything without making any actual claim.
Quantum quackery and New Age "mystical physics" begin in earnest in the 1970s with Fritjof Capra's "The Tao of Physics". Capra asserts that quantum physics confirms Eastern mystical teachings, a claim taken up in the 1980s by Hindutva pseudoscience.
*edited for grammar and to get to the point
It's akin to the convenient metaphor of "energy flow". In martial arts, oft-used phrases like "centering yourself", "allowing the flow of ki" and "breath power" are essentially descriptors for complex (and many times extremely subtle) physical behaviors. Yet on the surface, they seem to describe the existence of something like The Force. While I don't go as far as to claim that this "force" does not exist, in my experience the majority of its associated phenomena seem to be based in complex, but very concrete, physics and biomechanics. Even so, as my first Aikido teacher said, when you act as if the ki is real, you get demonstrable results whether it's objectively real or not.
The problem with the misuse of quantum theory terminology is that people actually believe that modern physics really concretely relates to how they can make money appear from nowhere. You know by now that I am not a die-hard materialist and in fact am very spiritual but I like to keep my knowledge domains nice and distinct. Quantum physics is for understanding the domain of the extremely small. Material prosperity is another domain which can (and should where useful) employ metaphors built on quantum physics, but ought to be intellectually honest and not misapply ideas.
For some background in quantum physics: Visit Wikipedia
Posted by Steve in Peak Performance | Permalink | Tag this post with del.icio.us
Comments
" The Secret is not Quantum Physics, they only use it to explain how the secret works.."
I AM LISTENING TO THE TAPE RIGHT NOW AND SEVERAL TIMES "THEY" STATE: THOUGHTS ARE THINGS...AND REFERENCE QUANTUM PHYSICS AS IF THIS IS PROVEN FACT.
I AM STILL LOOKING ON FOR ONE IOTA OF PROOF THAT THIS IS TRUE. I AM A SPIRITUAL PERSON WHO LOVES THE IDEA OF SCIENCE AND SPIRIT COMPLEMENTING EACH OTHER.HOWEVER UNTRUE STATEMENTS AFFECT BOTH SPHERES ADVERSLY.
Posted by: foxee | Jun 2, 2008 2:37:36 PM
Marcia, I might be missing the point... of your comment (and James's comment as well). Did I mention a house full of money? You seem to be responding to a straw man - that I am a frustrated skeptic trying to explain away something that I lack the faith to make work. I don't believe I gave any indication that such is the case.
I sometimes employ goal setting methods using hypnosis and NLP, interacting with my subconscious mind to ensure an outcome that's ecological for me and for everyone around me.
Now, does my explanation of how goal-setting works, since it posits a different explanation than the Law of Attraction/Ramtha/Abraham-Hicks worldview invoking "Quantum Mechanics", prevent me from getting results?
About tradition and old ideas: New is not necessarily better or more true, and traditions are not necessarily always bad. The logical fallacy of chronological snobbery (seriously, Google the term) is at play in the knocking of tradition and old ideas simply because they are old.
Second, The Law of Attraction and the Secret are not even new, in fact they are standard-issue traditional "New Age" ideas which go back quite a ways and are currently being promulgated by Eckhart Tolle and "Ramtha" among others.
Having said all that, Marcia, we agree on a couple of things. First, I won't be finding joy in a house full of money. That house, thought it would be nice to have, would be orthogonal to a joyful existence in my case. Second, humanity knows very little indeed.
Peace,
Steve
Posted by: Steve | May 8, 2008 4:37:54 PM
How sad for you to miss the point. Your not getting that new car or house full of money shows that perhaps it honestly meant little to your joy and passion for life. We are ourselves, no matter what. We can be pitifully trying to live up to other people's ideals of what is important, or follow what resonates in our being when we use the great gifts of imagination and feeling. So what if others are fightened and close themselves off with tradition and old ideas. What we know about Quantum Mechanics makes us realize how terribly little we know. You will find what you look for. Have fun!
Posted by: marcia miller | May 2, 2008 12:25:27 AM
You people are cynical!!!
You do not know what faith is and you have no faith! U question everything, because you are afraid of the fact that "The Secret" might just be true!!! In the study of Quantum Physics scientists have agreed that the world of the atom is completely different from our world. All the the creator of "The Secret" meant with using Quantum Physics in the book/ dvd is the small partical like electrons etc. can vibrate and that it can move from one person to another!!! U are make too much out of this! The Secret is not Quantum Physics, they only use it to explain how the secret works... (the human body vibrates etc) U are all idiots and know nothing about science! U are a lot of mad cynical scientists trying to unprove something that a five year old boy allready understands!
Posted by: James | Feb 18, 2008 10:14:28 AM
loan rate payday till
Posted by: loan payday home till | Jan 20, 2008 1:15:44 AM
cash loan advance payday
Posted by: my loan payday cash | Jan 17, 2008 10:13:28 PM
costume hannah montana
Posted by: montana birthday hannah | Jan 16, 2008 3:41:11 PM
professional psychic medium
Posted by: psychic robyn medium | Jan 15, 2008 7:26:32 AM
mlm leads lead
Posted by: lead leads mlm | Jan 4, 2008 12:43:07 AM
online 260free prescription hydrocodone
Posted by: hydrocodone 260free online prescription | Dec 7, 2007 5:45:56 PM
hydrocodone stay
Posted by: hydrocodone dosage | Oct 25, 2007 5:42:55 PM
soma akane
Posted by: relaxer soma | Oct 1, 2007 8:20:21 AM
make leads mlm
Posted by: mlm based leads | Oct 1, 2007 5:38:46 AM
consolidate shop student loans
Posted by: student loans consolidate of | Sep 27, 2007 4:46:20 PM
i have to second mark's opinion on this thought "when you act as if the ki is real".
you are a great writer steve
Posted by: fitline | Aug 6, 2007 11:12:15 PM
Wow, I'm glad I found this blog. You're a very intelligent writer Steve. I have been looking at both ends of the spectrum recently but tend to agree more with what you are saying. You said,
"when you act as if the ki is real, you get demonstrable results whether it's objectively real or not."
Completely correct. I always say that it's not the thing believed in but the belief itself which produces the result! I'm currently making a podcast series on belief and the power of the subconscious mind.
Excellent work!
Posted by: Mark McManus | Apr 25, 2007 12:20:36 PM